Why an active or passive approach to investing matters
By: Joyce Tan
Combining active and passive approaches to investing may further diversify a portfolio, manage overall risk, and potentially help to optimise risk-adjusted returns and improve overall fund performance.
Retail investors are constantly bombarded with information on how to make their money work harder. One such debate is about the active and passive approaches to investing, with some investment managers strongly favouring one strategy over the other.
In a nutshell, proponents of active investing attempt to beat the market by seeking outperformance from actively managed funds while those of passive investing believe in lower fees and delivering whatever the market returns are — good or bad.
The two strategies each have their own merits. Depending on market conditions and investment objectives, fund managers may choose one strategy over another.
Still, the active versus passive approach doesn’t have to be an either/or choice. Combining both strategies can further diversify a portfolio, manage overall risk, and potentially help to optimise risk-adjusted returns and improve overall fund performance.
What is Active Investing?
Active investors create portfolios by making a judgement on which securities they believe will outperform (to buy or hold) versus those that will underperform (to sell, not buy or not hold).
This involves in-depth research as well as ongoing buying and selling activity, which fund managers need to continuously monitor to exploit profitable conditions. By doing so, it allows fund managers to take advantage of short-term trading opportunities, which increases the odds of outperforming the market.
Active investing can be adopted for both equities and bonds. For equity investments, active managers may adopt different investment styles such as value or growth strategy.
For bond investments, fund managers seek to predict potential changes in interest rates, which would affect bond values, while taking into consideration bond prices, returns offered and the creditworthiness of issuers.
Most fund managers believe that active investing works better in inefficient markets, where there is less information available, for example, in relation to small-capitalisation companies, emerging markets, and so on. Arguably, this market inefficiency creates opportunities for fund managers to achieve outperformance through security selection.
Morningstar has a stronger conviction in the use of active managers for high-yield bonds due to market inefficiency, limited passive product advancement, competitive fee differentials, liquidity issues and poor benchmarking¹.
Some constraints of active investing include higher expenses, inappropriate investment styles in different market conditions, and no absolute certainty in choosing winners.
What is Passive Investing?
Passive investing involves closely tracking an investment index by buying and holding all or a representative sample of the securities in the index.
As no research is needed and lower transaction costs are incurred due to less frequent buying and selling of securities, the management fees and operating expenses of passive funds will typically be lower than those of active funds.
Passive investing often provides greater portfolio diversification as investors essentially invest in a wide range of securities across an entire index. An example of a passive approach is to buy an index fund that follows one of the major indices like the Euro STOXX 50 or the S&P 500 which includes 500 large companies listed on the New York Stock Exchange or NASDAQ.
Whenever these indices change their constituents, the index funds that follow them automatically follow suit, selling the stock that is exiting and buying the stock that is becoming part of the index.
The rapid growth of passive fund management is partly due to the emergence of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) which track an index, a commodity, bonds, or a basket of assets like an index fund. Unlike unit trusts, an ETF trades like a stock on a stock exchange. ETFs typically have higher daily liquidity and lower fees than unit trusts, which make them an attractive alternative for individual investors.
Some fund managers believe that passive investing tends to work better in efficient markets, such as the US, where assets are more likely to be fairly priced and due to more insights and analyses conducted on the securities listed in the market. As such, it won’t allow an investor to make higher returns than other investors in the same market.
However, passive investing has its constraints too. The returns of funds using this strategy will fall when the overall stock or bond market falls in accordance with the markets they track. In funds using a passive investment strategy, it is also not possible to select securities flexibly for defensive portfolio positioning, as these funds are designed to replicate or sample the underlying index. Also, as such a fund’s performance is tied to the performance of its underlying index, it may sometimes perform slightly weaker than the index due to fund operating costs.
The Best of Both Worlds
Generally, many investors favour the active investing approach in less efficient markets and the passive approach in very efficient markets. But it may be worth considering funds that combine active and passive investment strategies so as to harness the benefits of both investment approaches.
Chief investment officer at Lion Global Investors, Mr Teo Joo Wah, said: “Utilising a combination of low cost ETFs for efficient markets and competitively priced active funds for inefficient markets is likely to improve returns for investors.”
Many sophisticated investors have blended these two approaches, reducing expenses by allocating to passive strategies in some markets, while using active strategies in areas where they believe they can generate excess returns over the market.
According to Morningstar¹, it is important that investors think about active and passive funds holistically to get the right exposure to the right assets, be aware of liquidity and trading risks and maximise risk-reward at a total portfolio level, and reducing costs where possible. In particular, it noted that while investment returns are not guaranteed, fees are definite, so minimising fees should be an underlying principle when thinking about the investment selection process.
When aligned with the investment objective, a combination of active and passive strategies can harness the advantages of each approach.
To learn more about a fund that combines active and passive investment strategies — the LionGlobal All Seasons Fund — visit www.lgidirect.com.sg/allseasonsfund for more information.
About the LionGlobal All Seasons Fund
The LionGlobal All Seasons Fund is a fund of actively managed funds and ETFs, combining both active and passive investment strategies.
The fund comes with a low total expense ratio capped at 0.5 per cent p.a., including an annual management fee of 0.25 per cent p.a.
With a widely-diversified portfolio of funds and ETFs, comprising bond and equity funds, the fund is designed to better weather investment risks in all economic seasons.
The fund has two portfolio options — “LionGlobal All Seasons Fund (Standard)” and “LionGlobal All Seasons Fund (Growth)” — to cater to investors of different risk profiles.
Lion Global Investors Limited (“LGI”) is a company incorporated in Singapore and a member of the OCBC group.
This publication is for information only. It is not an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any securities/investments and does not have regard to your specific investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs. All applications for units in our funds must be made on application forms accompanying the prospectus. You should read the prospectus and Product Highlights Sheet for details, available and may be obtained from Lion Global Investors Limited (“LGI”) or any of its approved distributors, before deciding whether to subscribe for or purchase units of the Fund. Investments in the Fund are not obligations of, deposits in, guaranteed or insured by LGI or any of its affiliates and are subject to investment risks including the possible loss of the principal amount invested. The performance of the funds is not guaranteed and the value of units in Fund and the income accruing to the units, if any, may rise or fall. Past performance, as well as any prediction, projection, or forecast on the economy, securities market, or the economic trends of the markets are not necessarily indicative of the future or likely performance of the funds. Any opinion or estimate provided in the publication is made on a general basis and is not to be relied on by investors as advice. Investors must make their own assessment of the relevance, accuracy, adequacy and reliability of the information provided and make such independent investigations as they may consider necessary or appropriate for the purpose of such assessment. LGI reserves the right to make changes and corrections to its opinions expressed here at any time, without notice. Accordingly, no warranty is given and no liability is accepted for any loss arising directly or indirectly as a result of you acting on any information, opinion, forecast, or estimate contained herein. You may wish to seek advice from a financial adviser before making a commitment to purchase the Fund. In the event that you choose not to seek advice from a financial adviser, you should consider carefully whether the Fund is suitable for you. The Fund may invest in financial derivative instruments such as futures, options, warrants, forwards and swaps for hedging purposes or for the purpose of efficient portfolio management.
The references to any particular company is intended for illustration purposes only and is not indicative of Lion Global Investors Limited’s intention to invest in such company or a recommendation to readers to invest in the securities of such company or its products or services.
LGI, its related companies, their directors and/or employees (collectively known as “Related Persons”) may have positions in the products mentioned in this publication. LGI and its Related Persons may be engaged in purchasing or selling the products mentioned in this publication for themselves or their client. LGI does not take into consideration the tax implications of the income earned as the tax position of each person is different. Investors are advised to seek independent tax advice on their personal tax position arising from investing in the fund.
© Lion Global Investors Limited. All rights reserved. (UEN/Registration No. 198601745D). LGI is a Singapore incorporated company, and is not related to any corporation or trading entity that is domiciled in Europe or the United States (other than entities owned by its holdings companies).